Possibly best on the island
Neighborhood: Menemsha
Phone: +1 508 645 9454
Email | Website | Map | add to Travel Bag (NEW)
Click here to call Beach Plum Inn Restaurant Toll Free
This restaurant has been called "the most romantic restaurant on Martha's Vineyard" and many consider it the best, considering the ocean view enjoyed from every table. The menu, which changes daily during the peak season, features regional cuisine with an island twist, and guests can choose from a four-course prix fix or order a la carte. Beef Wellington has been a staple for 45 years, and there are always selections of locally caught seafood, often seasoned with herbs grown on the grounds. It also accommodates catered functions for up to 200 guests.
Reviewed by: Brian from Boston, Massachusetts, USA on Feb 13, 2006
Food great, service lacking
As seasonal Chilmark residents for the last 25 years the Beach Plum was one of our favorite island traditions. We are happy that the executive chef James McDonough has been retained by the new ownership yet are displeased by the overall drop in quality in the restaurant. We arrived 10 minutes late on a weekday in June and were greeted by a hostess with the most dour expression I have ever seen. The 25 minute wait for our wine to be served could possibly have been forgotten if it were not for the continued ineptitude and rudeness of the waitstaff. Alas.... all good things must come to an end.....we will miss our delicious meals at the Beach Plum Inn and fondly remember the days of yesteryear............
Would you recommend this to a friend?
No
Why? / Why Not?
Great location......service not up to par with prior owners
Skip it
...
Reviewed by:A Yahoo! Contributor from New York, NY on Feb 11 2006
A night to rember
It something special to watch the fishing boats heading back out of menemsha harbour and realize th...
Reviewed by:Edward from new york on Mar 13 2005
